Proprietorship vs LLP vs OPC vs Private Limited: Which One Fits You?

Start as a proprietorship if you are one person testing a business with little risk. Choose an LLP if two or more partners want limited liability with light paperwork. Choose a private limited company if you want investors or plan to give shares. A one person company suits a solo founder who wants limited liability now.

How do the four compare?

Surcharge and a 4% health and education cess are added to the tax rates above. For a company on the 22% option, the surcharge is 10% whatever the income, so the effective rate is about 25.17%.

Why does liability matter so much?

Because it decides what you can lose. A proprietor who cannot pay a supplier or a loan can be pursued for personal savings and property. In an LLP or a company, the business is a separate legal person. The debt is the entity's, and your loss stops at what you put in or agreed to put in.

How much does that matter for a small seller? If you hold little stock, take no loans and sell low-risk goods, not much. If you import, give credit, sign a lease or employ people, it matters a lot. One caution: banks usually ask directors of a small company for a personal guarantee, and that guarantee brings your personal assets back in for that loan.

What does the tax difference look like in rupees?

Take a business profit of Rs 10 lakh and of Rs 30 lakh, with no other income, using the rates on the Income Tax Department's pages for assessment year 2026-27.

Surprised? A company's 22% applies from the first rupee, while an individual climbs through slabs. The gap narrows in practice, because an LLP can pay its partners remuneration and a company can pay its directors a salary, and both reduce the entity's profit. That money is then taxed in the person's hands at slab rates. A company that pays out dividends leaves the shareholder to pay tax on them again. So do not pick a company to save tax at this size. Pick it for liability, credibility with larger buyers, or investment.

Which one if you are...

A solo online seller

Begin as a proprietor. You need a PAN, a bank account and a GSTIN, since marketplaces ask for one. Our guide to the GST registration process walks through it. Move to an OPC or a private limited company when you start borrowing, importing or hiring, or when a large buyer insists on a company.

Two partners

An LLP fits two people who will fund the business themselves. You get limited liability, no compulsory audit below the thresholds and two yearly MCA forms. If you expect to bring in an outside investor within a couple of years, start as a private limited company and skip the conversion.

A founder who wants investors

Private limited. Investors want shares, and only a company has them. It also lets you set aside shares for employees later. The registration process is the same whether you raise money next month or next year.

A professional

A consultant, designer or doctor working alone is usually well served by a proprietorship: simple, with slab rates. Two or more professionals practising together often choose an LLP. Check your own council's rules first, because some professions restrict practising through a company.

What about the one person company?

An OPC is a private company with a single member. Only an individual who is an Indian citizen can form one, whether resident in India or not, and a person can be a member of only one OPC. You name a nominee who steps in if you die or cannot act.

Earlier, an OPC had to convert once its paid-up capital crossed Rs 50 lakh or its average turnover crossed Rs 2 crore. That rule is gone. Since 1 April 2021 an OPC can stay an OPC at any size, and can convert to a private limited company whenever it chooses, by adding a second member and director and filing Form INC-6.

The mistake people usually make

Incorporating a company for the name on the visiting card, then ignoring it. A company with no sales still owes an audit, financial statements and an annual return each year. The additional fee reported for late annual forms is Rs 100 a day per form. Two forms left for a full year is about Rs 73,000, for a company that earned nothing. And closing is not free either: Form STK-2 needs affidavits and indemnity bonds from each director and a statement of accounts certified by a chartered accountant.

The opposite mistake is staying a proprietor too long, signing leases and taking credit in your own name while the business grows. Review the choice once a year. Before you decide, see the real numbers in our company registration cost breakdown.

Frequently asked questions

Read next